Living with Stout Man means a lot of adventures that involve ranking
things, tasting things, and usually both. Never have I met someone who
so loves to make top five lists. So it was not really surprising when he
suggested a pilsner taste test - a thoughtful concession to basically
the only kind of beer that I like (it is NOT his favourite).
Here's
how it worked: Stout Man bought five pilsners (I was not told which
ones), which he poured into numbered tasting glasses. I tasted each one,
taking careful notes (of course), and then ranked them from favourite
to least favourite. Stout Man then revealed the secret beer identities,
and we marveled at how my unbiased preferences did or did not line up to
my regular beer purchases. Yes, marriage can be this exciting!
#saturdaynight
I am not a beer expert like
Stout Man, and I really only drink pale lagers, so I don't have his
meticulous process, but I do okay. I smelled each contender, sipped it
carefully, and tried as much as possible to identify subtle notes of
whatever. Here are my judgments, from least to most preferred:
5. Stone Hammer Pilsner
The colour was very light - the second palest overall. That's as detailed as I can get about colour, so deal with it.
Right
away I noted a strong, sweet, fruity smell - like apples. This was
underscored by a faint odor of burnt caramel; usually a pretty appealing
feature, especially in concert with apples, but not what I'm looking
for in a beer. The taste was also sweeter than I prefer, although
mercifully there wasn't much of an aftertaste.
I
know what I want in a pilsner - light, crisp, a little bit of body and
some fizz (an area where this beer also came up short). Stone Hammer
seemed like it was trying to be a different kind of beer. Altogether too
sweet and bread-y for my taste. Like expecting a refreshing bite of
apple and finding yourself with a mouthful of French toast instead.
You
might recognize this one from the fun, colourful can - a hype to which
the contents were sadly unable to live up. The smell of this one was
clean, light and metallic - definitely promising. It was also pleasantly
fizzy.
The metallic quality translated better
into scent than taste, as it became the overwhelming feature on the
palate. I'll just say it: this beer tastes uncomfortably like blood. I
feel like taking my iron pill that day might have been overkill.
It's
too bad, because Old Style had some of the best features of a pilsner -
the fizziness was on point, it was light in colour, and crisp, with
basically no aftertaste (in my notes I wrote, "not my fave taste but at
least I'm not still tasting it.") Unfortunately, these good qualities
were overwhelmed by the vampire lager quality.
This
one was right in the middle of the five on the colour spectrum. It was
the first one I tried, and I felt right away that I wasn't going to be
very good at this because I could not detect a smell at all. I ended up
snorting some into my nostrils (elegant). The smell is VERY faint, a
thin citrus whiff.
In taste, the citrus
promised by the scent is basically non-existent. This one has a malty
flavour I wasn't thrilled by, but it only lasts a second. In fact, this
beer has never heard of aftertaste - basically immediately after
drinking it, I have forgotten it exists. In that sense it would probably
make a good session beer, but I do prefer something more refreshing and
with a bit more fizz.
I liked it - it was a
bit bold in taste for a pilsner, which I admire, without being
overwhelming. I needed a little more overall character though. I don't
think I would remember ever tasting this if I wasn't writing it down
right now.
Full
disclosure: this is my go-to beer order, so I was relieved that it
ended up placing so high. It was the darkest of the five in hue, with a
very faint citrus smell not unlike the Creemore, although with a bit
more follow through.
The taste was a little
maltier than I would usually go for, with a great citrus back-kick. The
words I used in my notes were "ambitious" and "well-constructed" and I
stand by them. It tasted like it fancies itself a more full-bodied beer
but isn't quite there (I also wrote "keep dreaming, little guy!").
The
Steam Whistle had a perfect refreshing fizziness, and the citrus saved
the more full taste that I wouldn't usually care for. I was surprised to
find it was Steam Whistle, which I always felt had a skunk-y edge that I
didn't taste here; Stout Man posited that the green bottle could have
that effect, and for this test we were using tall cans.
My
surprise favourite! I detected absolutely no smell (this might actually
have been the one that went up my nose - or maybe that happened twice).
Already I'm on board; no smell means light and sessionable.
The
taste was a perfect pilsner balance: just fizzy enough, a very slight
malty aftertaste to add some interest, along with a tiny skunk-y kick.
This is what I thought Steam Whistle tasted like - who knew that all
along, Pilsner Urquell was my favourite beer?
There's
nothing else to say about this one because there is nothing else to it,
and that's how I like my pilsners. Not quite forgettable - just
inconsequential enough to make it easy to order another.
Cheers!