It's a lovely looking
auburn brew--clear, and crowned with a luxurious, fluffy, off-white
head. As I expected, there is a cloyingly sweet nose that does, for all
the world, smell convincingly like a butter tart baked with maple syrup.
The mouthfeel is quite thin, which doesn't work in this beer's favour.
Its taste is, given the potent aroma, surprisingly restrained. There
are sweet, buttery caramel notes, as well as slow-rolling maple
elements. A bit light, however, on both malt and hops, with only a tinge
of bitterness on the back end.
This is a
curious beer. It smells both potently delicious and a little bit
revolting. Because of the strong smell, I expected comparable flavour,
though I found it tasted slightly thin. This beer would likely prove
pretty scrumptious poured over vanilla ice cream, but as a standalone
brew I found it a bit baffling. Too sweet and too thin makes for an
unusual combo. Still, the parties involved with the Butter Tart Ale are
to be commended for innovating a truly unique beer. Not my cup of tea,
but a genuinely inventive ale.
Rating: 6.5 out of 10.